By Jesús Longas ·

The Impact That Leaves No Mark
A carbon fiber panel leaves the factory in perfect condition. During a transfer, it takes a sharp blow. It arrives at the assembly line, is inspected visually, and nothing is visible. It is assembled.
On metal, that impact would have left a dent. On a composite, it may leave almost no trace on the surface, yet still have damaged the interior of the laminate. This is what the industry calls BVID.
This article explains what it is, why it’s such a concern, and why packaging is a part of the problem that’s almost never considered.
What Is BVID
BVID stands for Barely Visible Impact Damage. It is the damage that a low-energy impact causes to a composite material without leaving a clear mark on the surface.
A carbon-fiber or fiberglass laminate consists of layers bonded together by a resin. When struck, the surface can almost return to its original shape. Inside, however, the following may occur:
- Cracks in the resin between the fibers.
- Delamination: the layers separate from one another.
- Fiber breakage in the impact zone.
The external mark is usually an indentation measuring just a few tenths of a millimeter. Under normal lighting and during a quick inspection, it goes unnoticed. To detect it, a non-destructive testing method—such as ultrasonic testing or thermography—is required.
Why It’s Such a Concern
Internal delamination reduces the part’s ability to withstand loads, especially compressive loads. The part appears sound, but it no longer has the strength for which it was designed.
With use, repeated loads can cause this damage to progress. What began as a minor impact during a transfer may manifest months later, while in service, as a defect that requires repair or replacement.
That is why the BVID is handled with great care during aeronautical certification. Composite structures are designed to withstand a level of damage that is considered undetectable by visual inspection. That margin is intended to account for impacts sustained during the aircraft’s operational life—not for those that accumulate before the part is installed.
An impact during transport depletes a margin that isn’t meant for it. And no one knows about it.
Where it happens: between plants
A composite part doesn’t travel just once. It leaves the manufacturer, goes through finishing, painting, or inspection, and arrives at the assembly line. Wings, fairings, nacelles, or rudders are moved several times, often across countries.
Every loading, unloading, and transfer is an opportunity for impact:
- A hand truck that sets the load down abruptly.
- A pallet that drops a few centimeters on the loading dock.
- A package that shifts inside the truck when the brakes are applied.
The damage occurs at a specific point along the route. But if it is discovered at all, it is found out later: during the delivery inspection or, worse, even later. By then, it is unclear when or where it happened. The supplier, carrier, and customer argue over liability without any data to go on.
Why Standard Packaging Neither Protects Nor Provides Information
The same solutions are used repeatedly at plants in the industry:
- Bubble wrap and tape applied directly to finished surfaces, with the piece resting on metal workshop trestles.
- Wooden cradles and hand-cut foam, one per item, which are used for shipping and then discarded.
- Cardboard or wooden boxes padded with foam for medium-sized pieces.
They all have two fundamental limitations.
The first: the support is not continuous. The part rests on just a few points. Upon impact, the energy is concentrated right there. Furthermore, the foam loses its cushioning capacity with each use and crumbles, which increases the risk of foreign object damage (FOD).
The second issue: they don’t record anything. If the packaging absorbs a strong impact, no one knows about it. The receiving inspection checks the surface, and the surface reveals nothing. The decision to perform a non-destructive test is ultimately based on suspicion, not on data.
What composite packaging must do
If the risk is damage that isn’t visible, the packaging must do two things: prevent it and, if it doesn’t prevent it, alert someone.
- Support shaped to match the actual geometry. A cradle that mimics the shape of the part distributes the load across the entire contact surface. No stress concentration points, no sharp edges on finished surfaces. Thermoforming allows this cradle to be manufactured directly from the part’s CAD model.
- Material that does not degrade or release residues. An engineering thermoplastic retains its properties for hundreds of cycles, is washable, and does not produce fibers, splinters, or foam residue.
- Impact logging. A sensor that measures acceleration and records the date, time, and magnitude of each impact exceeding a threshold set for that part. Upon receipt, the data is read before opening the package: inspection is based on data, not suspicion.
- Traceability by shipment. Identification of the packaging linked to the part’s serial number. This makes it possible to determine at which stage the impact occurred and who is responsible for correcting it.
- Validation through testing. Drop, vibration, and stacking tests on a prototype, with a report that can be included in the part’s quality documentation.
None of this is new on its own. What’s missing in the industry is integrating it into returnable packaging, rather than sticking an adhesive label on a single-use wooden crate.
In summary
In the composites industry, the most costly impact is the one you can’t see. And a significant portion of those impacts occurs before the part even reaches the aircraft: during transport between plants.
Packaging is not a consumable. It is the last line of defense between a certified part and damage that no one will be able to explain.
At CTE, we’ve spent decades designing and manufacturing thermoformed returnable packaging for the automotive, machinery, and defense industries. Today, we’re working on a modular system for aerospace parts of all sizes, featuring a cradle customized to each part and an integrated impact log.
Do you move composite parts between plants? Tell us what parts and how you package them today. We’ll let you know if a pilot program makes sense.